75 Hard isn’t marketed as a fitness program; it’s a "mental transformation" program.
This program has some very stringent rules. First, you must complete two 45 minute workouts each day but one must be outside. Second, you must follow a very specific diet which does not allow for cheating or consumption of alcohol. You also are expected to drink one gallon or 3.8 liters of water each day and read 10 pages of a nonfiction book. Finally, you need to take a photo of yourself everyday to show your progress.
This program is for the individual who feels stuck and needs a complete psychological "reset." It’s designed for those who thrive on binary outcomes—success or failure. It’s excellent for building uncompromising discipline and proving to yourself that you can handle extreme discomfort.
On the other hand, 75 Soft emerged as a community-driven response to the intensity of the original challenge. It recognizes that for many people—especially those with full-time jobs, families, or a history of burnout—the "all or nothing" approach can be more discouraging than helpful. This version is more flexible and most participants aim for the 75 days straight but often will keep going if they miss a milestone along the way.
For this program, you are expected to eat well overall and only drink alcohol on social occasions. In addition, you only need to do one 45 minute workout each day and leave one day each week free to have an active recovery. Instead of a gallon, you need only consume 3 liters of water a day or around 3 quarts of water and finish off by reading 10 pages of any book.
The 75 Soft is for the person looking to build long-term habits without the risk of injury or mental exhaustion.
So which is better? It depends on your specific goal. If you want to build mental toughness, the 75 Hard is better because the rule that you must restart if you mess up at all requires that you develop extreme attention to detail. On the other hand, if you want to develop healthier habits, you should use the 75 soft since it has time scheduled for "active recovery". This is more realistic for the goal of lifelong fitness.
If you want to lose fat rapidly, the 75 Hard is for you because the sheer volume of two workouts each day creates a massive calorie deficit. If you don't have enough time for that due to a busy lifestyle, the 75 Soft is perfect since it only requires you to fit in one workout a day
Consequently, the program for you is based on your goals and starting point. The 75 Hard requires you to sprint through a mental minefield and its often hard to maintain once the 75 days are over while the 75 Soft may not give you the same ego boost but the habits you form are more likely to to stick for years rather than weeks.
If you are prone to the "yo-yo" effect or going hard for a month and then quitting, the 75 Soft is the better way to go. However if you feel you've become soft, you might need a shock to the system which 75 Hard provides. Let me know what you think, I'd love to hear.





